Facebook notification help?

I'm in a group on Facebook and we have a group chat going on messenger. Every time there's a new message, I get a notification on Facebook. I have gone through all my settings on Facebook, on messenger, within the group chat. I can't seem to figure this out. The only options I have are to turn off the notifications for the group chat all together (which would also turn off the messenger notifications, which I still want to receive), or have both messenger and Facebook notifications on.

I'm in a different group that also has a group chat and I don't have this problem. I'm able to get the messenger notifications for it, but I don't get Facebook notifications.