Valentines for Him?

mars • || 1-1-16 || |-/
So, I'm looking to get my boyfriend something for Valentine's Day, but I'm soooo lost! I've never had a Valentine! He loves everything I do: the same bands, same games, same hobbies. But I want to get him something meaningful, something thoughtful. Not just a bottle of cologne, yano? Who has experience with this, and what do you think I should do???