Too small?

El
Hey girls! So I've been planning on getting a specific tattoo for a while now, and yesterday I finally went to the tattoo shop to make my appointment. The artist told me that the specific tattoo that I wanted was too small and would look bad. 
This is the tattoo I want, he said the stars would have to be at least the size of a quarter. I was planning on putting it on the back of my arm and it would not fit at that size. 
Do you guys agree or disagree with what he's telling me about the sizing??
Thanks!