Doc A Tot vs. Etsy handmade!

Everyone and everywhere I keep reading that the Doc A Tot is a must have...
Ive also done my research and found some similar very nice handmade ones on Etsy.
Im wondering if the handmade will compare or if I should just stick to the Doc A Tot? 
Anyone have a Doc A Tot or Esty one?
If yes, what is your opinion on it? Please comment!!!