Little help here?

So I was dating this stud I fell in love with at a homecoming football game.. we started dating and a year and a half later for some reason all feelings I had for him just weren’t there anymore. Poof. Gone. So I did what I thought was right and broke it off saying he just didn’t do it for me anymore. (Demi Lovato ref lol) then I meet this cool new Pisces and we get along wonderfully. The sex is the best I’ve ever had but for some reason I can’t connect with him as strong emotionally as I did with my ex. The new guy (we’ll call him Billy) says I’m the love of his life, he loves me more than any girl ever, and proceeded to ask me out after like a week of hanging out and I said yes

>.<