how to choose between 2 guys?

so i started talking to this guy a week or two ago then the next day i reconnected with an old coworker and eventually started talking to him too. both guys are amazing and super sweet and i really enjoy them both!

thing is i went out with my old coworker last night and hooked up with him and he says he’s ready to make it a relationship. except i think i like the other guy more. what do i do? i’m not a very confrontational person!