Picking Sibling names is the worst- Gideon

I have a 21 month old named Gideon Reese (shared a pic just cause he's pretty damn cute!) and we are trying for baby #2. Holy cow, we disagreed on baby names the first go round so we are slowly discussing and it's worse this time!!!

I like:

Isaac

Elijah

Deacon

Gabriel

I gravitate to biblical names but it doesn't have to be.

We like Evelyn nn Evie for a girl. Hubby is set but I'm worried it won't FEEL right.

Did Anyone else think names were harder after their first?

Bombard me with name ideas, either gender!