In love with two guys at the same time.

So, last yr around June, I met a weirdo but very hot (in all the ways possible) dude at work... He's 11 yrs older than me, but gosh looks my age (I'm 22) and I had a crush on him, long story short I started hooking up w him couple months later... Then almost six months later I met another one OMG (my current bf) and I totally fell in love with him, cuz he's so innocent, fun, romantic and all that.

Well , while dating him... It was so hard to stop seeing the first guy... And I told him I got a bf and that I feel very comfortable around him and that we should stop seeing each other, but he was like you can stay with both of us...

Now I'm confused. I really love both of them and damn, srsly it's not just sex... It's the moments we shared.

What should I do?