Traditionally masculine name for a girl?

Risa • Middle school English teacher | Married My College Sweetheart 10/15/05 | 3x Girl Mama to Punkin (10/12/07), Peanut (09/04/16), and Pickle (08/28/18)
My hubby and I have chosen one name for our Squish, regardless of the sex. The name that we have chosen is traditionally a masculine name (not as traditionally masculine as James, or Michael, etc.), but we think that it works just as well for a girl. When DH told my MIL, she was surprised and said, "I've never heard that for a girl." Our minds are made up, but I wanted to get a general sense of what everyone else thinks... (I would share the name, but we want to keep it a surprise and my SIL and my brother's gf are both also expecting, and I don't know if they use this app.)