Which ring looks more like an engagement ring

So my bf got me a ring for valentine's day and yesterday we got me a ring with a morganite stone as an engagement ring. I don't have either yet because my ring from valentine's day was being resized and should be sent to me soon, and the engagement ring with the morganite stone has to be made because my finger was too small to resize a size 7. I am a little worried that my valentine's ring might steal the show from my engagement ring, but I haven't gotten a chance to take a picture of my engagement ring yet, but I really liked the morganite stone. What do you think?