Can your cherry get popped twice ?

I recently had sex and after doing so , I looked at my partners shirt and he had a blood stain on it and I asked if he was bleeding and then he looked at his whole shirt and saw a good amount of blood . I've only saw this when I first had got my cherry popped, that was two/three years ago and I'm not spotting at all . I've had sex multiple times since then and with multiple people and it's never happen before. I'm just wondering if your cherry can pop twice ?