Opinions on anal

So i been very curious to try anal. Me & my boyfriend tried it once before & it hurt so bad but good at the same time but im scared to 💩 on his D lol. One time when we were having sex it was night time/dark & he accidentally stuck it in my ass & it hurt so bad but after the pain was gone it felt good. I also like when he fingers my hole or eats it. is it weird to be in to ass play?