Baby name drama

So I planned on naming my son Atticus Justin. Justin is my fathers middle name so I called him to ask if he’d be okay with us using it and he said yes then asked what the first name was going to be. I told him Atticus and he said that Atticus Justin didn’t sound right and didn’t make sense. I don’t know what to do now. I’m dead set on naming him Atticus but I don’t want to name him after my father if my father doesn’t like the name. Do I change the middle name?? We also were thinking Atticus Ray after my husband dad but I feel like if I change the name now after I already asked my dad it will upset him and cause more drama. I’m just so confused I love the name either way. I don’t know what to do.