Condoms were a fail

Tried to start using condoms again with my bf and it was a sad fail. Literally couldn’t feel anything with the condom. It barely even fit on my bf dick. I told he needs to measure it so if we can find one the right size then hopefully it’ll work. For now we are going back to the pull out method. Yes I know that method is like playing Russian roulette but I don’t know what else to try. I have tried birth control and definitely do not want an iud 😖😖 (just sounds painful) I have come to terms with the fact that I could end up pregnant. I’ve already been tested for diseases and look forward to testing again to start the new year off right.

Any good advice will help.