What Are the Best Breast Pumps in 2025?

Figuring out which pump to buy can be overwhelming. While they’re all regulated by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) to ensure their safety, there are several different types, which fill slightly different niches:

• Manual: These are best for light pumping. They’re often quiet and cheap and don’t need any power since they’re operated by hand.
• Battery-powered or electric: If you pump regularly, look for something fast and efficient with stronger suction. These pumps can be single (one breast at a time) or double (both breasts simultaneously).
• Wearable: Pumping when you’re on the go or multitasking means you need a discreet, hands-free option.

Some pumps claim to provide “hospital-grade” (more powerful) suction, which is helpful if you have a low milk supply or you’re pumping for more than one baby.

When you pick, you should consider the size of the pump’s flange—also called a breast shield—which fits over your nipple and areola for suction. A good flange fit lets your nipple move a little in the funnel without causing rubbing and excessive swelling. A poor fit can cause pain or reduce your milk flow.

If you don’t know your flange size, measure your nipple diameter at its widest point in millimeters, then add one to three millimeters. For example, if you measure 21 millimeters, the shield should be around 24 millimeters.

It’s normal if your nipple size on each breast is slightly different. If that’s the case, go with the one that’s larger.

How did we choose these breast pumps?

On this list, we’ll break down each pump’s pros, cons, and key features. Other than the pump’s comfort and performance, we’ll also look at how well it fits different lifestyles, budgets, and breast sizes.

Since you’ll use your pump more than once, we’ll also evaluate how easy each product is to maintain and clean.

Comfort and performance

The S1 is a popular choice. Most moms think that it’s comfortable, efficient, and convenient. It’s also quiet and portable, with women reporting that they have no issues using it while at work or on the phone.

Late-night feedings are also easy enough, thanks to the built-in nightlight.

You can play around with a variety of suction speed and strength levels, and the adjustable massage feature stimulates letdown and makes pumping more comfortable—though it can take time to get used to.

The pump remembers which settings you last had it on, which saves you a lot of time. However, no matter what settings you choose, the pump will turn on in expression mode, which is a bit rougher. You’ll have to manually switch it to letdown mode.

Other features

Moms praise the LCD timer that shuts down the pump after 30 minutes, which will help you keep track of time without constantly checking your phone or watch. There’s no self-timer in the letdown phase, though, and unlike other pumps, that mode doesn’t shut off after a certain amount of time.

The pump has a built-in rechargeable battery. Some say it takes a long time to charge when you first pull it out of the box, but they like that they can use it even while it’s plugged in.

Accessories

One drawback that some moms mention is that the bottles (two come included) and pump kit feel cheap. Some report difficulty finding accessories like new bottles, flanges, and backwash protectors, and they also say that parts are expensive.

The pump comes with two flange sizes, 24 mm and 28 mm. If you need something smaller, you need to buy that separately.

Cleaning

The closed system design involves multiple parts that require thorough cleaning, which can be time-consuming to disassemble, wash off, and put back together. Some of the parts are clear, which also makes them easier to lose when you’re cleaning.

The flanges are one-piece units that connect to the bottle. Some find it harder to clean the interior since you can’t disassemble them further.

Is the Spectra S1 Plus Electric Breast Pump worth the price?

According to most moms, while maintenance can be a little tricky, the S1 Plus’s portability and user-friendly features make up for it.

Spectra offers a two-year warranty on the motor and a 90-day warranty on pump parts. This nontransferable warranty only covers manufacturer defects—meaning you’re on your own if there’s damage from accidents, misuse, normal wear and tear, or improper use.

Comfort and performance

Moms say the S12 is an affordable option for those looking for a hands-free pumping solution. It’s wearable and quiet—although still noticeable, judging by reports. The suction has nine adjustable levels, which gives you a lot of variety.

However, some moms report issues with the pump’s durability, particularly with the motor and battery life. The problems can lead to one side suddenly not working or having noticeably stronger suction.

Moms also report issues with their milk leaking, potentially getting into the pump’s diaphragm area, which connects to the interior motor. You’ll need to pay extra attention when putting the pump together to avoid that. Unfortunately, some people say it leaks no matter what you do.

It’s also worth noting that this product is flagged as a frequently returned item on Amazon.

While it’s great for casual or on-the-go use, some moms find it less efficient for exclusive pumping, and it may not fully empty the breast for everyone. Since this is a wearable pump, it might not work as well for you if you have a bigger chest.

Other features

On the upside, the pump has a memory function that tunes it to your most recent settings. It also features a large LED display for easy monitoring.

There’s no alignment guide for nipple placement, so you have to feel it out each time. A few moms mention that they have trouble lining up their nipples and that the suction cups may not fully stick to their breasts, which can cause some of that leaking we mentioned.

Accessories

The pump comes with a USB-C charger, but you’ll need to get a second one if you want to charge both sides simultaneously. Some moms also point out that charging both sides simultaneously still results in different battery lives on each side.

The pump comes with 24 mm flanges, but for an additional cost, you can get the 15-, 17-, 19-, 21- or 27 mm insert.

Cleaning

Most say that cleaning itself is easy. However, the general consensus is that it’s a hassle. Like the Spectra S1 Plus, this pump has a lot of parts that need to be disassembled, cleaned individually, and then reassembled.

Is the Momcozy S12 Pro worth the price?

The S12 tries to strike a balance between performance and affordability. Many moms say that it does, but given the issues about the pump’s durability and milk leakage, it might not be right for you if you already have difficulty producing enough milk.

Momocozy offers a 30-day no-reason return policy for unused and unopened products with the original packaging and accessories intact. There’s also a one-year warranty (two years in the EU), which also covers normal wear and tear—but not misuse or unauthorized modifications you make to the pump.

Comfort and performance

The Elvie is a premium, wearable pump that’s designed to fit directly into your nursing bra. Moms say it’s one of the quietest pumps they’ve tried, and it’s often unobtrusive enough to go unnoticed.

The pump has four customizable suction rhythms. It automatically switches to expression mode when it senses letdown and pauses when the bottle is full, which moms appreciate.

However, a handful of people say they have issues with the suction not working, which leads to them sometimes having to clean the pump or disassemble the parts to fix the problem. The suction also fails if the disc is wet.

Some report issues with milk leaking and overflowing into the motor hub, which makes it hard to clean. The battery also seems to drain more quickly than expected, which can affect suction strength.

Other features

The main appeal is that you can operate the pump via a smartphone app, which offers features like real-time milk volume tracking, session history monitoring, and phone-based control of pumping sessions.

However, some note that it would be better if the app sent you an alert when the timer ran out to keep you from pumping longer than necessary.

A significant number of moms also say that the app glitches. Sometimes, the measurements are off, meaning that the pump will stop before you’re really done.

Accessories

Moms like the variety of the flanges. The pump comes with 24 mm and 28 mm flanges, and upon request, you can also get a two-pack of 15-, 17-, or 19 mm nipple cushions or 21 mm flanges for free. If you’re worried about the fit, you have four bra adjusters to choose from and two carry bags for when you’re on the go.

It comes with two chargers so you can charge both sides simultaneously.

Cleaning

Cleaning this pump is a time-consuming hassle (as with many others on this list). Most say it requires a lot of attention to detail and that it’ll take some time for you to get familiar with how to strip down the parts, but that’s a common issue with electric pumps, not unique to this product.

Is the Elvie Double Electric Breast Pump worth it?

This pump tries to appeal to the modern mom by being portable and app-operable. While most say it works well enough, others say it’s overpriced, especially considering the issues with the app.

While you won’t be able to return it once you break the tamper seal, Elvie provides a two-year warranty on the hub for the pumps and a 90-day warranty on the washable components.

Comfort and performance

Unlike the other pumps on this list, this one aims to be an “occasional-use” pump, meaning it’s compact and portable enough to use in emergencies, at family events, or before you head out to work. Moms say it is a little noisy, though.

The suction works well enough for most people, especially considering that it’s not designed for everyday use. However, many say the suction isn’t as strong as other pumps. Some also point out that the suction on battery power is noticeably weaker than when the pump is plugged in.

The vacuum pressure isn’t very variable, and you can’t adjust the speed, so it might be hit or miss when it comes to getting enough milk.

A handful of moms also say it broke down after a few weeks of use.

Other features

This pump doesn’t have a built-in battery, and you’ll need to get those separately. However, it does include the charger. The flanges are angled, which helps moms stay comfortable by allowing them to sit or lean back slightly while pumping instead of hunching over to keep milk flowing into the bottle.

Accessories

The pump comes with 28 mm and 30.5 mm flanges, but if those won’t fit, you can also purchase 21-, 24.5-, 33-, and 36 mm inserts. Moms say that the pieces were easy to assemble. However, a handful say that pieces were missing when they received the package (if that happens to you, of course, you should contact the seller).

Cleaning

This is another pump with a closed system design that makes it easier to keep hygienic. It’s easy to clean and prevents milk from backing up in the pump motor, which means you’ll be able to keep parts dry, clean, and working.

Is the Evenflo Feeding Advanced Single-Electric Breast Pump worth it?

This pump is convenient and portable, and many say the price is fair for what you get. However, this may not be the pump for you if you want something long-lasting with reliable suction power.

You can return the pump within 30 days if it’s unopened and in the original packaging with the safety seal intact. If you buy from an authorized retailer and register your breast pump, you’ll also receive a 90-day warranty policy covering manufacturing defects.

Comfort and performance

The Haakaa is a popular choice for experienced and new moms alike. It’s a manual pump, meaning you’ll have to squeeze it by hand. However, moms say it’s relatively easy, quick, and painless.

The suction is on the gentler side, which can be a downside if you have difficulty getting milk out. The pump’s not meant to be a full replacement for a “regular” (electric) one and won’t fully empty the breast. It works best when used alongside breastfeeding or another method of pumping. It’s a decent option if you need to collect milk that would otherwise soak into a nursing pad.

One of the main criticisms seems to be that the volume indicated on the pump doesn’t always match the actual amount of milk you can collect. For example, one version claims to hold 100 milliliters or “4 ounces,” but 100 milliliters is actually closer to 3.38 ounces instead.

Notably, if you have a higher milk output or bigger breasts that need more suction, you may need to upgrade to the 5-ounce (150-milliliter) pump.

Other features

Since this is a manual pump, it doesn’t need batteries or a charger. The lack of a mechanical motor also means that moms don’t feel the need to hide away to save their families from the noise. However, with weaker suction, it may slip and spill milk if it gets jostled—either by you or a fussy baby.

The silicone also gets slippery when it’s wet, so moms advise that you should keep it dry to maintain the suction.

Accessories

Unless you buy this in a bundle, it doesn’t include a cap or stopper to prevent milk spillage or contaminants. You’ll need to buy those separately. That’s a downside, but moms say that these accessories are usually cheap and easy to come by.

Cleaning

This pump is easier to clean than electric models. There’s no tubing, motor, or valves to worry about getting dirty or backed up. The single piece of silicone is easy to wash and sterilize. It’s also dishwasher-safe.

Some report that the pump has a strong plastic smell. To fix that, try applying a baking soda paste and soaking it in vinegar and warm water before cleaning with (also warm) soapy water.

Is the Haakaa Silicone Breast Pump worth it?

If you’re looking for a convenient pump without any complicated bells and whistles, the Haakaa pump is a decent choice for many moms. It’s a great low-cost backup or starter option.

You’re eligible for a full refund if you return the pump within 14 days of delivery. There’s a 30-day return policy for other products, which only applies if they’re new and unopened.

Comfort and performance

This is a passive milk collector, which means it can fit inside your bra to catch milk if you’re too busy to actively pump or nurse. It also works if you’re nursing from one breast while the other has a letdown.

It’s a wearable, hands-free alternative to wearing breast pads, so you can save breast milk and build up a stash. However, if you’re bigger-chested or have a milk output higher than the three-ounce capacity of this product, you might not find it as comfortable or practical as you’d like.

There are mixed opinions about how well it actually fits under clothes. Some say it isn’t noticeable, while others say it’ll make you look like you’re wearing an overstuffed shirt.

As with the Haakaa pump, there’s no motor, so you don’t have to worry about noise. Moms also say it doesn’t get knocked off as easily as other, similar collectors, although many say that the Haakaa has better suction.

Other features

Moms like the easy-pour spout, which lets them transfer milk into storage containers without issue. The flat bottom also lets it stand up on its own—with the caveat that it’s easy to knock over.

Some retailers sell versions without a plug or stopper (even though it’s included in the pictures), so make sure you check the product description carefully and contact customer service if you have any questions.

Accessories

This is a single-piece collector, so you’ll need to buy any bottles and storage bags separately. However, some bundles include travel pouches, which make the pump more convenient and portable.

Cleaning

Due to the silicone, you’ll probably get hairs, lint, and dust stuck on it. However, cleaning them off—and cleaning in general—isn’t an issue for most moms. Like the Haakaa, you can clean this by hand or in your dishwashing machine.

Is the Boon TROVE Silicone Breast Milk Collector worth it?

According to most moms, this is a decent option if you’re looking for a discreet, comfortable, and affordable option for capturing letdown and building a stash without a full-fledged pump. However, it might not be the best option if you need to express more milk or have a higher milk supply.

Like other pumps, the official manufacturer offers a 30-day return policy if the product is unused and has its original ticketing and tags attached.

A good breast pump is about more than just the specs—it’s about what works best for you, whether you’re exclusively pumping or just planning to catch the occasional letdown. Here are our recommendations:

• Best pick overall: Spectra S1 Plus Electric Breast Pump
• Single electric: Evenflo Feeding Advanced Single-Electric Breast Pump
• Wearable: Momcozy S12 Pro
• Smart (advanced): Elvie Double Electric Breast Pump
• Manual: Haakaa Silicone Breast Pump
• Easy to use: Boon TROVE Silicone Breast Milk Collector

Pumping (and breastfeeding in general) is a process of trial and error. Do your research, read lots of reviews, and don’t be afraid to try a few until you find your perfect fit.