Update: I'm not being ungrateful, I liked what he got me but I thought it was something else because we had been talking prior about what I would like and I told him I wanted something that I could wear daily like a ring. So there is communication. So I expected something more.. Plus the bag he gave me was huge and he kept smiling as though there was something on the bottom but it was just tissue so I was kind of disappointed. Yes he remembered as all you have mentioned, but he should remember since I mentioned it prior. I'm not saying I hated his gift I use it everyday but I just expected that by not we would be moving closer to that step not going backwards to when we started dating.